Was She Bullied, or Did the Truth Cut Too Deep?

by Bill Brenner on October 4, 2012

A good friend disliked yesterday’s post, “The Fat Lady Sang, And It Was Beautiful.” His main criticism was that I centered it on my own weight battles, which I traced back to Crohn’s Disease, Prednisone and addiction.

Mood music:

[spotify:track:1DH4YwHHGBkWO8dX3JISjl]

Livingston, a morning anchor at WKBT in La Crosse, Wisconsin, went on air after getting an email that read in part:

Surely you don’t consider yourself a suitable example for this community’s young people, girls in particular. Obesity is one of the worst choices a person can make and one of the most dangerous habits to maintain.

After reading the email she received, Livingston then took her critic apart, noting that he doesn’t know her well enough to pass judgement. She also accused him of bullying her. I applauded her for doing this because I felt her critic wrongly assumed she and other overweight people simply made a choice to be obese. My argument was that weight trouble can come from a variety of factors and that this guy was out of line.

My friend felt my response was based on assumptions and that framing my complaint in the context of my past issues with Prednisone and Crohn’s Disease didn’t jibe with the news woman’s situation. “Does the anchor woman share those same issues?” he asked. If she doesn’t and her obesity is simply a matter of her not taking care of herself, he said, my comments were off the mark.

“I also have issues with those that view the original comment as bullying,” my friend continued. “Some view things through the eyes of responsibility. Others just want to place blame and make excuses.”

For all we know, Jennifer Livingston falls into the latter camp, he said, concluding, “What you wrote is representative of not having all the facts.”

I agree that many people make excuses for being overweight and that their real problem is laziness and gluttony. There’s a joke making the rounds where a fat guy tells his doctor, “The problem is obesity runs in my family.” The doctor responds, “No, the problem is that no one in your family runs.”

When someone lets their body go to crap because they don’t feel like doing what’s good for them, they are being bad role models, especially when it comes to their children and how they’re allowed to develop the same bad habits. I took one such parent to task for that a while back in “When Parents Fail.”

Unfortunately, a lot of people who work hard to be good role models and take care of themselves end up overweight anyway. One friend of mine gained a lot of weight because he developed a foot infection that left him unable to do much physical activity.

As for Livingston, I don’t know why she’s overweight, and I don’t care. These days, a lot of people are hired to anchor news shows because they look like supermodels. That Livingston was able to break through that and succeed in the industry speaks volumes. TV media is a cut-throat field and you don’t succeed unless you work your ass off. As far as I’m concerned, that’s an example of a good role model.

Livingston is also a good role model for showing that you don’t have to be someone else’s idea of perfect to be on TV or to do a job. It’s not just men who come in all shapes and sizes. Society says that women must be skinny to an unhealthy degree and look perfect. She’s not perfect, but that doesn’t mean everything she does is wasted.

Actually, I don’t think perfect role models exist. People do big things and overcome obstacles in ways that inspire others to do better. But they make big mistakes along the way. It’s called being human.

Finally, let’s look at Livingston’s use of the word bully. That’s what she called Kenneth Krause, the man who sent her the email. To me, a bully taunts you with names, making sure everyone in the vicinity can hear it, and makes threats. Krause did none of these things. He called her a bad role model for being obese and called it a choice. Obviously, I disagree.

This guy was mean, superior, judgmental, disrespectful, and prejudiced. He doesn’t think fat people should be on the air.

Fuck that.

But was Krause a bully? He didn’t threaten her or call her names in earshot of others, which is how I picture the act of bullying. I don’t think he’s a bully per se. But consider these definitions Erin (my wife and editor) found:

The American Heritage Dictionary defines a bully as “a person who is habitually cruel or overbearing, especially to smaller or weaker people.”

The fact that Krause only wrote in once probably doesn’t fit, but he was cruel and overbearing, especially to someone he thought was weaker. And he never apologized, saying instead that she should follow his advice.

More important, though, to bully, says AHD, is “to treat in an overbearing or intimidating manner”; “to make (one’s way) aggressively.” Krause did treat her in an overbearing way and he was aggressive about trying to get his own way: that she lose weight.

No matter where Livingston’s weight problems come from, what Krause did was wrong.

Disagree if you wish. But that’s my position.

Jennifer Livingston

{ 4 comments… read them below or add one }

Laurel October 4, 2012 at 4:41 pm

I totally agree. I don’t know when open season began on women’s bodies, but when a man feels it’s his responsibility to criticize a public figure based ENTIRELY on her appearance, he’s an asshole. And yes, his email was bullying.

Keith R. White October 4, 2012 at 6:57 pm

I believe the moral of the story here is no human being has the right to judge another human being. Nor do they have the right to force another individual to live by their standards. We are all different for a reason. The problem with “Freedom of Speech” is some people use it as a license to hurt, insult and yes “BULLY”. I was bullied as a pre-teen by someone just like Krause. Someone who believed they could control me and my life by using words and hurtful actions day after day. What Ms. Livingston did in response to Krause’s actions was STUPENDOUS!! I applaud her and every other person with the Courage and Self Confidence to stand up to these Bullies like Krause. It is the only way to deal with them, head on and full steam ahead.

Jessica Pozerski October 18, 2012 at 4:56 pm

She doesn’t look all that big to me. I mean, she isn’t skinny, and yes she is a little overweight, but she doesn’t look huge enough to deserve reprimanding.

Nancy December 25, 2012 at 4:53 am

My take on Krause’s message is that he felt she should be made invisible until such time that her appearance became (what he believed to be) acceptable for a woman on tv. So, to Krause, she shouldn’t be in the public’s eye in her current state. She should be in a job where she is properly hidden. Was that his message? It seemed that way to me. Maybe he hated that she defied some of stereotypes of the overweight. She was educated, hardworking, respected, well-groomed person in the public spotlight. She didn’t show a proper amount of shame. This must have irritated him. After all, what kind of message might that send? I think she is a very good role model. She has absolutely no reason to hang her head in shame, even if it might make Krause feel better.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: